Resources

For the past several years, home insurance has been one of the most significant headwinds facing Florida buyers and homeowners. Premiums spiked, carriers exited the state, and affordability took a hit that mortgage rates alone don’t fully explain. Now, for the first time, state data is confirming what Florida’s insurance reform legislation was supposed to produce: premiums are actually falling.

Florida regulators have reported that home insurance premiums are declining in 51 of the state’s 67 counties in 2026. That is not a projection or an industry forecast — it is data from the state’s own records. For Space Coast buyers who have been factoring sky-high insurance costs into their purchase calculations, and for sellers whose listings have been competing against affordability concerns tied to carrying costs, this is meaningful news.

Why Insurance Costs Were So High — and Why They’re Coming Down

Florida’s insurance crisis had two primary drivers: an unusually high volume of weather-related claims and a litigation environment that made Florida a national outlier. At its peak, Florida accounted for roughly 8% of all U.S. homeowner insurance claims but nearly 80% of all homeowner insurance lawsuits. The math didn’t work for insurers, and many of them left the state entirely.

The reform legislation passed by the Florida legislature in 2022 and 2023 targeted the litigation problem directly — capping attorney fees, tightening assignment of benefits rules, and reducing the financial incentive to file dubious claims. It took time for those changes to work through the system, but the results are now showing up in the data. Florida’s homeowner insurance lawsuit share has dropped to 41%, a dramatic decline from where it stood just a few years ago. Fewer lawsuits mean lower costs for insurers, and lower costs are beginning to flow through to policyholders.

What This Means for Space Coast Buyers

Insurance costs affect buying power in ways that often get overlooked. A buyer budgeting for a $380,000 home in Brevard County isn’t just calculating their mortgage payment — they’re calculating principal, interest, taxes, and insurance as a combined monthly obligation. When insurance premiums were rising sharply, that total monthly number pushed some buyers out of price points they could otherwise have qualified for.

Declining premiums work in the opposite direction. Even a modest reduction in annual insurance costs — say, $500 to $1,000 per year — meaningfully improves the monthly picture for rate-sensitive buyers. It also restores some of the affordability that was eroded during the worst years of Florida’s insurance crisis, without requiring any change in mortgage rates or home prices.

For buyers who were previously stretching to make the numbers work in neighborhoods like Viera, Rockledge, or Merritt Island, improving insurance conditions are worth revisiting. What didn’t pencil out 18 months ago may look different today.

What This Means for Space Coast Sellers

When buyers can afford more, more buyers enter the market — and more competition among buyers is good for sellers. The insurance crisis suppressed demand at the margin by adding carrying costs that pushed some buyers to the sideline. As those costs ease, some of those buyers return.

Sellers should also be aware that buyers and their agents are increasingly asking detailed questions about insurance costs during the due diligence process. Having documentation of your current policy, your premium history, and any mitigation features on your home — wind-rated garage doors, hurricane straps, a newer roof — gives buyers the information they need to get accurate quotes quickly, which reduces friction and keeps deals moving.

A Note of Caution: Relief Is Real, but Uneven

The statewide trend is positive, but it is worth being precise about what the data does and doesn’t say. Premiums are declining in 51 of 67 counties — that means 16 counties are still seeing increases or flat rates. Coastal properties, older homes, and properties in higher-risk flood zones may still face elevated insurance costs regardless of the statewide trend. The improvement is real, but it is not uniform.

Buyers should get insurance quotes early in the process — ideally before making an offer — so that carrying costs are fully understood before committing. The improving market makes this easier than it was a year or two ago, but insurance remains a variable worth pinning down rather than estimating.

If you have questions about what buying or selling looks like in today’s Brevard County market — insurance costs and all — reach out directly. Understanding the full picture of carrying costs is something I work through with every buyer I work with, and it makes a real difference in finding the right home at the right price.

Sources:
WPTV — State Data Shows Decreasing Home Insurance Premiums in 51 Florida Counties (Aug 18, 2026)
Spectrum News 13 — Florida Insurance Regulators Say Premiums Are Falling in 51 Counties (Aug 18, 2026)
Insurance Business — Florida Homeowners Insurance Lawsuit Share Drops to 41% After Reform Push

Data is considered accurate at the time of publication. This content is AI-assisted and has been reviewed prior to publishing.